Tell me I'm wrong but give me a better reason then you can't lift it as high. This works specifically well in open quarters. If there is traffic next to you lift straight up.
To Suitcase or not:
Horses for Courses
I say do what works as long as it is not a limitation...but question whether it is in fact limiting you.
If your saddle is under your arm--call it
suitcasing--you can only lift the bike so high before you hit your armpit. Most people work around this limitation by cantilevering the bike out to the side using the saddle for leverage just as you describe-lets call it
bikewinging. It works for lots of people who are very good racers, both men and women.
Ellen gets it...big logs make suitcasing difficult. Bike to the side FTW. Red Mill in the background (is that Mo?) looks to be fighting her bike.
From my observations I'd say that well over half the UCI women
suitcase or
bikewing. Based on this empirical evidence alone, I have to assume there may be some good reason women so often
bikewing. I don't know exactly why this is but perhaps it is due to women being
on average shorter and with less upper body strength than men (note "on average" because there are definitely female racers who are way more ripped than their male counterparts myself included).
Some of the top men do it too. Here's a very very good cyclist doing the
bikewing on his way to winning the Canadian National Championships.
If it works for people winning Nationals or UCI races it can't be all bad but
very few of the top male UCI racers
bikewing and there there must be a reason. I'll give you a couple reasons I don't like it.
1) It limits your ability to run very fast. Your body natrually wants to twist as you run. Your arms move opposite your legs and your upper body twists. When you
bikewing, your bike essentially becomes a part of your torso which makes running awkard and less efficient. When you hold the bike to your side your upper torso can more much more freely.
2) It limits your options. How do you go from
suitcase or
bikewing position to shouldering? That's simple to do if your arm is inside of the saddle. What happens if the barriers are really high? What happens if there is an unexpected pileup and you need to squeeze through a tight spot?
3) It increases the chances of dropping a chain. when you leverage the bike out an an angle, lateral forces are applied to the chain (gravity). If you or somebody else bangs a pedal when you are running it's much more likely that you will drop your chain than if your bike was vertical. Also, it's nearly impossible to set the bike back down without imparting lateral forces on the drivetrain. Again, if you bounce the bike when you set it down with lateral forces applied to the chain you are much more likely to experience chain drop.
4) Really good dismount technique should make
bikewinging not only unnecessary but downright hard to do. Look at photos or watch slo-mos of the fastest guys in the country/world doing dismounts and running the barriers. What you'll notice is that immediately prior to dismounting, they steer the bike away from their bodies. This subtle move not only gets the bike away from the body and opens up space to run, but it puts the bike slightly behind the rider so when you lift there is a little centripetal force acting on the bike which keeps it out to the side. If you don't steer the bike away from your body you
have to do something to get the bike away from your body after you pick it up--I think that's why most people end up
bikewinging. It's a natural response to less-than-ideal dismounts.
Take a look at this slow-mo from Day 1 Nittany:
First two riders (Thompson and Durrin) get it. It's subtle, but they both steer the bike away after their right hands are pushing down on the top tube but before they dismount. A+
Third rider (Maxx Chance) sets up late but impressively only takes 1 step before the stair
Fourth rider (Clark) dismounts with both hands on the hoods. 4 steps before the stair. I'm a huge AC fan but he's not somebody to use as a model for technique.
Fifth rider (Marion) also dismounts with hands on the hoods but limits it to two steps.
Compare & Contrast Curtis White (PVD last year) to Garrigan from above