I grew up in the 80s which meant listening to LPs and cassettes in cars. This was the high school days which means Sounddesign or Realistic modular units which had fair at best sonics. Some kids in Westfield had Japanese components with a pink noise detector, but at they end of the day it was about listening to King Crimson's Three of a Perfect Pair.
99% of TT setups will sound worse than your average CD components. Then there's also the quality of the vinyl pressings and how clean they are. A trick to improve your CD sound is to buy an external DAC. Most CD players have really low end chips, even ones at $500. Digital music is the same, get an external DAC.
50% of my listening is from streaming, Pandora/Spotify. Songs come on and an hour later I couldn't tell you for sure 3 songs I heard.
20% is from CDs, SACDs or DVD-audio
20% digital music from an ipod or similar device
7% vinyl 33/45
1% lacquer 78
1% cassette
1% 8 track... All rough estimates
For me, it's not only the nostalgia. I couldn't afford my own setup and my parents were never into records. So I would walk over to a friend's house just to listen to King Crimson on vinyl. Now I have some disposable income and spent more than I needed on a decent setup. The 78s are played on a German MC cart but it still sounds pretty crummy. Recordings from 100 years ago with 90 yo pressings on lacquer with no remastering will never sound like the Robert Johnson remasters from a few years back.
I'd like to know why kids today want to go to vinyl. Would be nice to know that they like to tinker and think about the process of choosing an album and reading through the lyrics on the jacket, fully emersed and not multi tasking. Well, at least that's what I do.
Typed this while listening to my portable Sony waiting for new tires...
