Current setup:
XC bike- Eggbeaters
Freeride bike- Time ATAC Z's
I was on Shimano for the XC bike a few years ago, but knees needed the float. Got some eggbeaters and they've been good for a couple years now, but I can see some bushing damage and feel some play developing, so it's time for a rebuild (or probably a new pedal since it's time for something new). Curious about the new Look pedals, too. They appear nice and light.
Had Mallets on my freeride bike originally. Snapped a spindle literally riding off a 6" curb in front of my apartment (I'm sure the damage was pre-existing, and that was just the straw that broke the camel's back). CB had a rebuild kit out to me within a few days, and I rode those pedals until I demolished one side of one pedal on some rocks at Diablo. It was time to retire them anyway. Moved to Time ATAC Z's, and I've been happy with them. I've noticed lately some unintended unclipping, so it's time for new cleats. Otherwise, I like the Times better than the Mallets, but the new Mallet design with set screws is intriguing, and might convince me to go back.