Waughaw is hard, but Fiddler's & Iron Bridge are just in another league entirely.
Waughaw is not the toughest climb in NJ. It's steep but short and has a false flat recovery section. I will say though that BB's time up it (on StravaTubeBook of course) is just ridiculous.
http://app.strava.com/segments/667941
I have yet to try Iron Bridge or Fiddlers Elbow but I have found this climb out of Bloomsbury to be one of the most painful climbs I have encountered in the area.
Schaff Rd Climb (579)
http://app.strava.com/segments/693105
622 ft in 1.3 miles. There's a hairpin turn where the climb pitches up even more. Ouchy!
I'm pretty sure BB won HTT at least once. I need to make a special trip out to do some of those climbs soon.
My A
Millbrook
Coleman
Fidlers
Iron Bridges
Zellers
My B
Jenny Jump
Quimby
Danville
Ryan
Lake Justit
Yeah Matt I would agree. I use to live off Benton Rd and had to hit that a lot. What about Gaisler?
Just a note to anyone interested in riding Middle Valley Rd/Zellers...the bridge at the bottom is currently under repair and, as far as I could tell, not open. Still got in N 4 Bridges and Black River Rd, which ended up being plenty.
You can jump on the Columbia trail from west mill and take it to middle valley. It's only a half mile or so. This gets you beyond the bridge and at the base of the climb... No excuses!!!
Doesn't Fiddlers get progressively less steep at the top?