I was just having this conversation with
@The Kalmyk , you have that control over your kids through middle school to try a bunch a different things and at least one of your kids is likely put into things that you enjoy, partially because they want to be like mom or dad.
And then you get to 9th grade and they still do it but maybe start to be iffy on it and then 10th grade it explodes.
I experienced this with my son and have seen other parents I know from riding have a similar experience.
After 5 years with NICA and 4 years as a head coach, I found that NICA is for middle schoolers or beginners. All of the basic stuff is great, the skills, the framework for teams, team building, the adventure stuff and the races.
For the kids that start as 6th graders (and now 5th), it is easy to keep them engaged for a few years since there is a huge amount of strength gained in middle school and there is still a lot of skill to be gained / expanded on / adding technical terrain etc. Also, you have coaches that are at a level where they can 1. keep up with 95% of the kids, 2. teach kids the skills. 3. The middle school racing is just all about riding fast and finishing, so anyone can do it.
But here is the gap:
1. Kids become faster than all but the few coaches that actually ride. On my team, I lead the fast group (SPICY
🙄) and the other coaches used to draw straws on who would help with this group as they would always get dropped. It was me and 2 other coaches that could actually keep up with the 10 fast kids and maybe only me that could challenge them to hold my wheel. Typically the two coaches that could keep up are needed to lead other groups. So you end up having an issue with keeping the fast kids engaged. This is amplified by the fact that NICA provides zero means for any training guidance. Middle school is ride more makes you faster. Varsity? That stops working.
2. The majority of coaches aren't skilled enough on the bike to teach kids outside of the basics. On-trail training is a must and most coaches can't do it, let alone teach it.
3. The no jumping thing. Liability, yes, I get it, and I know jumping is more accepted and y'all have the jumping area that
@Mountain Bike Mike founded, but it needs to be more normalized and encouraged to keep the older kids engaged.
4. Most NICA courses don't prepare kids for actual racing outside of NICA. The basics are the same but the courses are often dumbed down so much, racing outside of NICA can be a shock to the system. PA NICA has legit pushed the boundaries on this with some technical courses, its good to see. We had a coach that had a complete Karen moment at MASS bear creek race because the course was too hard and there weren't enough marshals.
In all honestly, if we get 1 out of 10 to be a life long cyclist, that is a win.