I don't really care what you guys do cuz I kinow you are trying to have fun. But I must admit, I do think the mouth should be covered. Just cover it with a smiley sticker or something and then it she can't offend anyone. I have a really sick sense of humor and can joke with the best, but I do think that this can be offensive and better to be safe that get ourselves a bad name from those that are not really stating their negative feelings on the whole thing.
What she said.
Cut a red latex balloon into a Miss America smile and glue it to Shaniqua's face. Then nobody is offended, everyone is happy. Would I be offended by ET or a gorilla or Obama? Absolutely not. They're clearly innocuous.(Unless they have receptacles I'm unaware of.)
Was I offended by her? Not really, cause boys will be boys, but I do wonder the effect it could have on the reputation of MTBNJ. See, anyone who has been following the site is an insider to the joke and would be much less apt to be offended than the general public. But reputation is precious. It can take years to build and mere seconds to dismantle.
I did wonder how the ladies felt about it and I'm mildly surprised none bristled at the thought. I do think it would be more respectful to those ladies not to have a sex toy represent them.