SmooveP
Well-Known Member
A bunch of random thoughts on this subject, many of which I've mentioned in the past:
- "Sustainable" is a relative term. I've been riding Hartshorne for almost 30 years, and many of the trails were there long before I started, so they've mostly held up pretty well.
- Objectively, the problem areas affect less than 20% (maybe more like 5-10%) of the total trail length.
- The Park System is deliberately cautious in their approach to re-routing or making new trails. The last major project was adding the Rocky Point section, which was close to 20 years ago (I think). Some trails were closed (anyone remember Three Hills?), and nature hasn't totally reclaimed them yet. There is also a goal of preserving habitats for wildlife, so cutting new trails through untracked forest is unlikely to happen.
- Fixing eroded trails is a big engineering effort. Bringing in fresh dirt from an outside source is expensive and doesn't always work. The soil composition at Hartshorne is actually pretty good - way less sandy than Allaire, with a decent mix of rocks and roots to hold it together. The Park's approach has always been to maintain the trails without bringing in outside materials. I'm sure the Park has budget issues, too.
- "Fall line" trails are part of what make Hartshorne fun (at least for me). Not sure what the solution is. I'm sure some trails will have to closed eventually.
- Rogue trail building is bad. The fact that it's being done by so-called mountain bikers is bad for us.
- Changing weather patterns are making it worse. Weeks-long droughts turn the trails to soft sand and torrential rains wash it away. Is it me, or is torrential rain the only kind we get anymore?
- The Park schedules a handful of TM sessions a year at Hartshorne. They're usually pretty well-attended (20-30 people), but virtually no mountain bikers show up. Everyone I've interacted with at the Park has been great, and is receptive to input. Not sure what the exact history was between the Park and JORBA, or if it really matters.
I doubt that we as a group could agree on what needs to be done, so I guess we'll just keep on riding (and bitching).
- "Sustainable" is a relative term. I've been riding Hartshorne for almost 30 years, and many of the trails were there long before I started, so they've mostly held up pretty well.
- Objectively, the problem areas affect less than 20% (maybe more like 5-10%) of the total trail length.
- The Park System is deliberately cautious in their approach to re-routing or making new trails. The last major project was adding the Rocky Point section, which was close to 20 years ago (I think). Some trails were closed (anyone remember Three Hills?), and nature hasn't totally reclaimed them yet. There is also a goal of preserving habitats for wildlife, so cutting new trails through untracked forest is unlikely to happen.
- Fixing eroded trails is a big engineering effort. Bringing in fresh dirt from an outside source is expensive and doesn't always work. The soil composition at Hartshorne is actually pretty good - way less sandy than Allaire, with a decent mix of rocks and roots to hold it together. The Park's approach has always been to maintain the trails without bringing in outside materials. I'm sure the Park has budget issues, too.
- "Fall line" trails are part of what make Hartshorne fun (at least for me). Not sure what the solution is. I'm sure some trails will have to closed eventually.
- Rogue trail building is bad. The fact that it's being done by so-called mountain bikers is bad for us.
- Changing weather patterns are making it worse. Weeks-long droughts turn the trails to soft sand and torrential rains wash it away. Is it me, or is torrential rain the only kind we get anymore?
- The Park schedules a handful of TM sessions a year at Hartshorne. They're usually pretty well-attended (20-30 people), but virtually no mountain bikers show up. Everyone I've interacted with at the Park has been great, and is receptive to input. Not sure what the exact history was between the Park and JORBA, or if it really matters.
I doubt that we as a group could agree on what needs to be done, so I guess we'll just keep on riding (and bitching).