mattybaft - Dude, which side of your mouth should we listen to? the one that says even breathing on BSA land is a big no no, or the one that says that they are very MTB friendly. What is the guidance here according to your well informed insight? Please advise.
Unfortunately it's an issue of liability. The BSA is supportive of biking and any outdoors activity - this is pretty much "what they do". We ran 3 races on the property last year and have 5 lined up already this year, if not 7 or who knows, maybe more. But those races all come with liability waivers. That's really the catch in the discussion.
I know the BSA director and he has told me his job is to get the camp more involved with the community. Having said that, he can't open it up to anyone to ride at any time. That would risk everything he's got going on there - the camp, the scouts that use it, his job, etc. Not to mention the whole shooting range, bows & arrows, ATVs - the dangers are probably endless. Hell, you might get taken out by one of the pesky beavers.
I'm sure you understand, living in NJ. It's not a simple matter of "my house is your house," unless you add the "so long as you sign this waiver saying that if you get hurt you get to actually own my house."